Frustrated Etsy seller with his laptop open

Amazon Seller Account Frozen by a Trademark Lawsuit?

A brand owner filed a single lawsuit in federal court in Chicago naming a hundred or more online sellers at the same time. The list of sellers is attached to the complaint as an exhibit called “Schedule A,” which is why these are known as Schedule A cases. The court froze every listed seller’s account before anyone was notified. Notice was then sent by email, often to the address attached to the storefront. Sellers who did not hire a lawyer and appear in court had judgments entered against them, and the frozen money was turned over to the brand owner.

Most sellers in this position assume nothing can be done. That assumption is now often wrong.

In 2026, the federal appeals court that covers Illinois decided two cases that matter to sellers.

In the first, the court held that sending notice by email to a seller in China does not count as proper legal notice. An international treaty controls how court papers must be delivered to someone in China, and email is not one of the permitted methods. If a seller was never properly notified, the court never had authority over that seller, and a judgment entered without that authority is not valid.

In the second, the court threw out a judgment because there was no proof that the seller had ever actually sold anything to a customer in Illinois. Screenshots showing that a customer could have placed an order were not enough. Without a real sale in the state, an Illinois court generally has no authority over a seller located overseas.

Sellers often assume that a judgment entered a year or two ago is simply over. In the first case above, the seller waited about ten months after the judgment before doing anything. The court still allowed the challenge, because what mattered was that the seller acted within about two months of learning that the money had been taken. If you only found out when your funds disappeared, the clock the court cares about may have started then, not when the judgment was entered.

This is not automatic, and every case is different. But it is worth finding out where you stand before assuming the money is gone.

To tell you whether a challenge is worth pursuing, we would want to see the notice the platform sent you about the freeze, any emails you received from the brand owner or its lawyers, the date you first learned money had been taken, your sales records showing whether you ever shipped anything to Illinois, and the court papers if you have them. If you do not have the court papers, we can pull them.

We will tell you honestly whether the amount at stake justifies the cost of the fight. Sometimes it does not.

This page is general information about the law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not make you a client of the firm. Every case depends on its own facts, and results in other cases do not predict what will happen in yours.

Joel M. Huotari

Joel M. Huotari is a partner at WilliamsMcCarthy LLP in Illinois. He handles trademark, copyright, and e-commerce enforcement and defense matters in the federal courts of Illinois and Wisconsin, including Schedule A litigation in the Northern District of Illinois, where most of these lawsuits are filed.


Joel M. Huotari, Partner
WilliamsMcCarthy LLP
Email: jhuotari@wilmac.com
Phone: (815) 987-8982

Stay Informed

We regularly share insight in publications and our quarterly e-newsletter, Comments from Counsel.